Everton’s transfer history has been marred by several missteps, with signings like Davy Klaassen, Moise Kean, and Cenk Tosun failing to meet expectations.
However, one of their most significant errors may have been a player they let go.
A few years ago, Everton sold Ademola Lookman to RB Leipzig for £23 million.
At the time, this seemed like a smart move for a player who hadn’t shined at Goodison Park.
His subsequent unremarkable loan spells at Leicester City and Fulham appeared to validate Everton’s decision.
However, Lookman’s performances have dramatically improved over the past two years, elevating him to the status of one of the world’s top players.
Lookman’s rise to prominence was highlighted by his inclusion in the 30-man shortlist for the Ballon d’Or, announced on Wednesday.
While he’s unlikely to win, his nomination alongside stars like Erling Haaland, Kylian Mbappe, and Harry Kane demonstrates how far he’s come since leaving Everton.
Lookman’s outstanding season included a hat-trick in the Europa League final, 11 goals in Serie A, and three more in the African Cup of Nations, totaling 17 goals across all competitions.
His performances even attracted interest from Arsenal during the summer transfer window.
This remarkable turnaround suggests that Everton may have prematurely given up on a player who has now become one of the world’s best, making his sale potentially one of their biggest transfer mistakes.