Everton’s Goalkeeping Crisis: Dyche Considers Replacing Pickford Amid Poor Form
Everton Football Club finds itself in a precarious position as the new Premier League season unfolds, with manager Sean Dyche reportedly contemplating a significant change in the goalkeeping department. The focus of this potential shake-up is Jordan Pickford, England’s number one goalkeeper, whose recent performances have come under intense scrutiny.

The Toffees have endured a disastrous start to the 2023-2024 campaign, suffering defeats in all four of their opening league matches. This poor run of form has left the Merseyside club rooted to the bottom of the Premier League table, a position that has set alarm bells ringing throughout the organization. At the heart of these concerns is the team’s defensive fragility, with Pickford having conceded a worrying 13 goals in just four matches.
The nadir of Everton’s early-season struggles came in a recent match against Aston Villa. Despite building a two-goal advantage, the team’s defensive frailties were exposed once again as they capitulated, eventually losing the match 3-2. This collapse has only intensified the spotlight on Pickford’s performances between the posts.

According to reports from The Sun, Sean Dyche’s patience with his first-choice goalkeeper is wearing thin. The manager is said to be deeply dissatisfied with Pickford’s displays and is seriously considering making a change in the January transfer window if the current situation does not improve dramatically. This potential decision underscores the gravity of Everton’s current predicament and the pressure mounting on Pickford to rediscover his best form.
Interestingly, the same report suggests that Dyche may already have a replacement in mind. Newcastle United’s Nick Pope has emerged as a potential target for Everton, should Dyche decide to move on from Pickford. This link is not surprising given Dyche’s history with Pope, having managed the goalkeeper during their time together at Burnley. Pope’s name has reportedly been mentioned whenever Dyche has voiced criticism of Pickford’s performances, indicating that the Everton manager holds his former charge in high regard.

The potential availability of Pope adds another layer of intrigue to this developing situation. Newcastle are rumored to be open to the idea of transferring Pope, as they have their sights set on Burnley’s promising young goalkeeper, James Trafford, as a long-term replacement. This chain of potential transfers was set in motion earlier this year when Newcastle unsuccessfully bid around £16 million for the 21-year-old Trafford, as reported by Mail Sport in June.
Pickford’s tenure as Everton’s first-choice goalkeeper has been a long and largely successful one. Since his £30 million move from Sunderland in 2017, he has been the undisputed number one at Goodison Park. However, his recent form suggests that this long reign might be coming to an end. The gravity of the situation was perfectly illustrated in a recent match against Tottenham Hotspur, where Pickford’s poor touch allowed Son Heung-min to score easily, contributing to a humiliating 4-0 defeat for Everton.

Despite these recent struggles, it’s worth noting that Pickford’s overall record at Everton is impressive. In his seven years with the club, he has made 284 appearances across all competitions, keeping 77 clean sheets in the process. These statistics highlight the consistency and reliability that Pickford has provided over the years, making the current situation all the more concerning for Everton fans and management alike.
As the January transfer window approaches, all eyes will be on Goodison Park to see how this goalkeeping drama unfolds. Will Pickford be able to rediscover his form and retain his place as Everton’s number one? Or will Sean Dyche decide that a change is necessary to arrest the team’s alarming slide? The coming months will be crucial in determining the future of Everton’s goalkeeping position and, potentially, the trajectory of their season.