Leeds United’s recent match against Sunderland at the Stadium of Light should have ended in a impressive away victory for the Championship side. However, a last-minute blunder by goalkeeper Illan Meslier resulted in a 2-2 draw, denying Leeds the full three points. Despite this setback, Leeds’ defensive performance had been relatively solid in recent league matches, conceding only five goals in the Championship prior to this game.
The current defensive lineup, featuring players like Joe Rodon and Pascal Struijk, seems to inspire more confidence than some of the club’s past defensive acquisitions. This brings to mind the case of Robin Koch, a defender who struggled to make a positive impact during his time at Leeds.
Koch was signed from SC Freiburg in the summer of 2020 for £13 million, as part of a transfer window that saw several unsuccessful signings, including Helder Costa and Diego Llorente. The German defender never truly settled at Leeds, with his first season marred by injuries limiting him to just 17 league appearances. His subsequent seasons were characterized by subpar performances, culminating in a disastrous 2022/23 campaign that saw Leeds relegated to the Championship. During that season, Koch managed only five clean sheets in 36 league matches.
The failure of Koch’s signing is particularly frustrating when considering the player Leeds could have potentially signed instead. Ben White, who had spent the 2019/20 season on loan at Leeds, was keen on a permanent move to Elland Road that summer. White had played a crucial role in Leeds’ promotion to the Premier League under Marcelo Bielsa, featuring in every minute of their Championship campaign.
Bielsa had taken a liking to White, and football talent scout Jacek Kulig had described the young defender as a “warrior” during his time in the Championship. White’s performances at Leeds proved to be a springboard for his career, leading to a £50 million move to Arsenal, where he has continued to impress. In the 2022/23 season, while Koch struggled at Leeds, White contributed five assists from his defensive position for Mikel Arteta’s Arsenal side.
White would have been a more suitable fit for Bielsa’s Leeds immediately after their promotion, compared to Koch. However, despite White’s desire to return to Leeds permanently, the move fell through, and he instead signed a new contract with Brighton & Hove Albion. White’s agent, Alex Levack, confirmed that the player was disappointed about not being able to rejoin Leeds, stating that White had thoroughly enjoyed his time at the club and appreciated the support of the fans.
The failure to secure White’s services and the subsequent signing of Koch exemplifies the challenges Leeds faced in their recruitment strategy. While White has gone on to establish himself as a key player for a top Premier League side, Leeds are left to reflect on their decision to opt for Koch, who ultimately failed to meet expectations at Elland Road. This transfer saga serves as a reminder of the importance of astute decision-making in the transfer market, particularly for newly promoted teams looking to establish themselves in the Premier League.