Referee Anthony Backhouse faced intense criticism from Burnley fans after awarding Sunderland two late penalties during a dramatic conclusion to the match at Turf Moor. The home supporters loudly booed Backhouse as he left the pitch, frustrated by decisions that could have easily changed the game’s outcome.
Despite the controversial calls, Burnley managed to hold on for a 0-0 draw thanks to their goalkeeper James Trafford, who delivered two stunning saves to deny Wilson Isidor from the spot on both occasions. The tense moments ensured Scott Parker’s side avoided a late upset.
The first penalty, which sparked the most outrage, came after CJ Egan-Riley’s foul on Isidor as he charged towards goal. Replays revealed the contact occurred outside the box, yet Backhouse awarded a penalty. The second decision, involving Oliver Sonne’s challenge on Dennis Cirkin, was more contentious. Sonne lunged at Cirkin as he cut the ball back, leading to a spot kick that divided opinions among pundits.
Don Goodman, providing commentary for Sky Sports, sympathized with Burnley’s frustrations, suggesting they had every reason to feel hard done by. However, former Premier League referee Mike Dean offered a contrasting perspective. Speaking on Sky Sports, Dean defended the second penalty decision: “For me, this is a penalty. No complaints whatsoever. It’s a good call by the referee. [Cirkin’s] just nicked it back, and the Burnley player commits to the tackle, misses the ball, and clearly takes the man.”
Adding to Burnley’s grievances was their earlier penalty appeal, which was emphatically denied by Backhouse. Zian Flemming appeared to be fouled by Luke O’Nien inside the six-yard box just as he prepared to shoot, but the referee waved away the protests.
The result leaves Burnley frustrated with both their inability to secure victory and the controversial officiating decisions that defined the match.