Former Everton Scout Lauds Michael Keane’s Revival Despite Admitting He’s “Short on Ability”*
Everton’s 2025/26 season has already been a rollercoaster. After a promising August, September has brought a string of setbacks, culminating in a disappointing 2-0 defeat to Wolves in the Carabao Cup that ended their run in the competition. With results faltering, several players have come under fire—most notably striker Beto, who has struggled to make an impact.
Yet, amid the criticism, one player has stood tall. Veteran centre-back Michael Keane has stepped up impressively following Jarrad Branthwaite’s injury layoff, delivering commanding performances that have surprised many. It marks a significant turnaround for the 31-year-old, who was reportedly close to being released by the Toffees in the summer.
Former Everton scout Bryan King has been particularly impressed. Speaking about Keane’s resurgence, King said the defender has shown admirable professionalism and resilience: *“He knew he wasn’t going to be first choice after Branthwaite emerged, but he never complained. Injuries change things in football, and he’s come in and done a solid job. He might lack one or two things in terms of ability, but he’s brave, he’s honest, and he’s got a big heart. That’s why managers like David Moyes value him.”*
Keane’s importance has been reflected in Everton’s defensive record at their new home, Hill Dickinson Stadium, where they remain unbeaten and have yet to concede a goal. His form has raised questions about how Branthwaite will regain his spot once fully fit, potentially leaving Moyes with a welcome selection headache.
For a player who was nearly shown the door just months ago, Keane has become one of Everton’s standout performers this season. His story underscores the value of resilience and commitment—qualities that have made him indispensable in a squad battling to find consistency.