AliousVAR Drama: Ex-Ref Dean Raises Eyebrows with Contradictory Take on Brighton Escape at West Ham
A contentious moment at the London Stadium has sparked debate after Brighton’s Pervis Estupinan avoided a red card in their 1-1 draw with West Ham.
The incident saw Max Kilman left in visible pain following a challenge that divided opinion among officials and fans alike.
Former Premier League referee Mike Dean, providing analysis on Sky Sports, offered a puzzling assessment of the 21st-minute incident.
While acknowledging that Estupinan was “out of control” with “two feet off the ground,” Dean simultaneously labeled it a “50/50 call” after VAR review.
The apparent contradiction in his analysis has only fueled further discussion about the decision.
Despite referee Rob Jones initially showing a yellow card, many expected VAR to upgrade the punishment.
Dean explained that substitutions cannot occur during a review, suggesting this influenced the initial yellow card decision.
However, even after review, the original decision stood.
The stakes were particularly high with twelve minutes remaining, including added time.
Brighton nearly capitalized on their numerical advantage, coming close to a winner that was only prevented by a crucial goal-line clearance.
West Ham’s attacking trio of Bowen, Kudus, and Summerville were denied the opportunity to exploit what could have been a ten-man Brighton side in the closing stages.
The decision left Hammers fans frustrated, particularly given the potential impact a red card could have had on the match’s final moments.
Brighton’s escape has added another chapter to this season’s ongoing VAR controversies.
Alious
