Newcastle United’s summer transfer window was overshadowed by their unsuccessful pursuit of Crystal Palace defender Marc Guehi. After his standout performances for England during Euro 2024, Guehi became a priority target for the Magpies as they sought a high-caliber centre-back.
Despite submitting multiple bids, reportedly reaching as high as £65 million, Palace stood firm, rejecting all offers. On deadline day, Newcastle ultimately withdrew, leaving manager Eddie Howe without his top defensive target. Their only addition to the backline for the 2024/25 season was Lloyd Kelly.
With Guehi now entering the final 18 months of his contract at Selhurst Park, speculation has arisen about Newcastle reigniting their interest. However, competition for his signature has intensified, with Chelsea and Liverpool reportedly keen on the Palace defender. Newcastle, already navigating Financial Fair Play constraints, would need to shell out around £50 million for Guehi—a move that could severely impact their January budget.
Sky Sports journalist Pete Graves has cast doubt on Newcastle’s chances of returning for Guehi. Speaking on the *Transfer Talk* podcast, Graves expressed skepticism, stating, “I would be very, very surprised if Newcastle go back in for him [Guehi], considering the finances and how the previous negotiations unfolded.” Co-host Dharmesh Sheth noted that Chelsea’s interest might force Palace to reassess their stance, especially as Guehi’s contract nears its expiration, potentially lowering his valuation.
Given the high cost and fierce competition, Newcastle are now exploring alternative defensive options. One emerging target is 20-year-old Lens defender Abdukodir Khusanov, though Manchester City and Real Madrid are also tracking the young talent. Former target Fikayo Tomori has reappeared on Newcastle’s radar, with reports suggesting the AC Milan defender could be available for under £25 million in 2025—a figure well within the club’s financial constraints. Additionally, Benfica’s Antonio Silva is another option, though his £41 million price tag would consume a significant portion of Newcastle’s remaining budget.
While a return for Guehi appears unlikely, Newcastle remain determined to strengthen their defensive ranks with more financially viable alternatives.