AliousSunderland Dodged a £6M Disaster: How Missing Out on David Nugent Turned Into a Masterstroke
In the summer of 2007, Sunderland were locked in a high-stakes transfer battle with Portsmouth over the £6 million signing of Championship star David Nugent. On paper, Nugent looked like the perfect fit for a Black Cats side newly promoted to the Premier League—he had just netted 15 goals in 44 appearances for Preston North End. But while Sunderland narrowly missed out on his signature, what seemed like a disappointment quickly turned out to be a blessing in disguise.
From Top Target to Transfer Flop
Portsmouth, fresh off a 9th-place Premier League finish but starved for goals, matched Sunderland’s bid and ultimately secured Nugent’s services. However, his stint at Fratton Park quickly unraveled. Barely a month after signing, his relationship with manager Harry Redknapp began to sour. Despite scoring in a League Cup match against Leeds, Nugent was swiftly deemed expendable. Redknapp publicly hinted at selling him to raise funds, casting doubt over the forward’s future almost immediately.
Nugent’s Premier League Struggles Begin
Nugent’s Premier League output never lived up to expectations. In the 2007/08 campaign, he failed to score in 15 league appearances. While he finally netted his first Premier League goal in early 2009—ironically against Redknapp’s new club, Tottenham—it was a rare highlight. Over four top-flight seasons, including a loan spell at Burnley, he managed just 14 Premier League goals. Though he became something of a cult figure in the Championship, Nugent never adapted to the top-tier demands.
**Sunderland Strikes Gold with Kenwyne Jones**
While Nugent floundered, Sunderland shifted gears and brought in Kenwyne Jones from Southampton in a £6 million deal that also saw Stern John included. Jones proved to be a far more effective acquisition. In his first Premier League season, he scored seven goals and continued to be a reliable presence, eventually netting 26 goals in 94 league appearances before a record move to Stoke City in 2010.
A National Highlight, Then a Rapid Fade
In a curious twist, Nugent scored on his England debut in 2007 while still a Championship player—his only goal in his only international appearance, earning him the distinction of having the shortest goalscoring international career in England history. That moment, however, would be one of the few highlights of his time in the spotlight.
Different Destinies
While Sunderland remained in the Premier League until 2017, Portsmouth’s fortunes nosedived. They were relegated in 2010 amid financial chaos and bounced cheques, ending a turbulent era that included Nugent’s forgettable tenure.
Looking back, Sunderland’s failure to land Nugent in 2007—once seen as a setback—ultimately saved them from a costly misstep. Instead of being saddled with an underperforming forward, they unearthed a cult hero in Jones and maintained their Premier League status for nearly a decade. In hindsight, missing out on David Nugent was one of the best things that could have happened to the Black Cats.
Alious
