AliousSurprise Transfer Swap? Man United and Brighton’s Late-Window Talks Hint at a Logical but Unlikely Deal**
Earlier in the transfer window, Manchester United made efforts to sign Brighton’s dynamic young midfielder Carlos Baleba. However, the Seagulls were steadfast in their valuation, reportedly seeking a fee in excess of £100 million—similar to what they received for Moisés Caicedo. United, unwilling to meet that high price this summer, allowed discussions to cool off.
Baleba, 21, returned to Brighton’s starting XI for the opening Premier League fixtures against Fulham and Everton, despite battling a pre-season knee injury. He managed 69 minutes in the 1-1 draw against Fulham, but was subbed at halftime during the 2-0 defeat at Everton—officially for “tactical reasons.” Head coach Fabia Hurzeler expressed disappointment in the team’s performance but denied that Baleba’s underwhelming display was related to ongoing transfer speculation.
Without naming names, Hurzeler hinted post-match that certain players might be too comfortable in their roles and need to raise their standards—a likely message to underperformers like Baleba. Despite the recent interest, Hurzeler reaffirmed his belief that Baleba will remain a Brighton player once the transfer window shuts. The midfielder remains under contract until 2028, with an option for an extra year, and has shown a willingness to consider a move to Old Trafford.
In a twist, fresh reports suggest Brighton have initiated talks with Manchester United over 20-year-old midfielder Kobbie Mainoo. The England international appears to have slipped down the pecking order under new manager Ruben Amorim and is reportedly open to exploring other opportunities.
Transfer insider Fabrizio Romano, speaking via YouTube, emphasized that discussions are still at a very early stage: “There will be talks with Mainoo to clarify the situation. It’s not a done deal or even close—nothing advanced or concrete yet.”
Fans and pundits alike have been speculating about a potential late-window swap deal: Baleba to Manchester United, and Mainoo heading to the south coast. On the surface, such an exchange might benefit both clubs—United gain a promising midfield powerhouse, while Brighton secure a technically gifted young English talent who fits their development model.
But despite the intrigue, these types of last-minute swap deals are rarely straightforward. The complexities of valuation, wages, contract lengths, and player approval make it a challenging transaction to finalize before the September 1 deadline. The more realistic scenario could see United revisit Baleba next summer, while Mainoo’s short-term future remains uncertain—especially if Brighton’s interest fades or United opt to keep the academy graduate and reassess his role.
In the end, while a Mainoo–Baleba swap appears sensible on paper and appealing to fans, the practical hurdles could mean this logical-looking deal stays just that: an idea.
Alious
