Everton’s performance against Brighton and Hove Albion was better than the 3-0 scoreline suggests, but they ultimately suffered a clear defeat.
Despite dominating the first half, Everton found themselves trailing 1-0 at halftime.
A reversed penalty decision early in the second half proved crucial, and after conceding a second goal and Ashley Young’s dismissal, Everton’s chances of a comeback vanished.
Sean Dyche’s substitution choices were once again questionable, with one particular change causing significant displeasure among the Goodison Park faithful.

While the stadium had remained relatively full despite the poor result, likely due to it being the first Premier League match in months, the mood shifted dramatically in the 85th minute.
The introduction of Mason Holgate to cover for Young’s absence prompted a mass exodus of fans, with some even booing the decision.
This reaction highlighted the fans’ frustration with Holgate, whose career at Everton has declined sharply in recent years.
Once a promising young player, Holgate’s form has deteriorated, and unsuccessful loan spells have further damaged his reputation.
Holgate’s high wages and long contract have made it difficult for Everton to offload him, leading to frustration among supporters who view him as a liability rather than an asset.
The negative response to his substitution underscores the lack of progress at the club and suggests that, for his own benefit, Holgate should consider leaving Everton given the clear disapproval from the fans.