Alan Pardew, a prominent figure in English football, expressed sympathy for Everton following their 3-2 defeat against Aston Villa on September 14. Speaking on talkSPORT the next day, Pardew suggested that Everton deserved better from the match, particularly noting the impressive nature of Jhon Duran’s winning goal.
The game saw Everton initially take a surprising 2-0 lead at Villa Park, with Dwight McNeil and Dominic Calvert-Lewin finding the net. However, this advantage was erased by Ollie Watkins, who scored on either side of halftime. The match was ultimately decided by Duran’s exceptional long-range strike.

This loss marks the second consecutive match where Everton has squandered a two-goal lead, following a similar scenario in their previous game against Bournemouth. In that match, Everton dominated for 87 minutes before conceding three goals in the final 10 minutes.
Despite Pardew’s sympathetic view, the recurring pattern of losing substantial leads raises concerns about Everton’s performance. Questions arise about whether these collapses stem from mental factors, tactical issues in game management, or simply unfortunate circumstances.
Nevertheless, there are some positive aspects for Everton manager Sean Dyche to consider. Iliman Ndiaye showed promise against Bournemouth, and Calvert-Lewin has scored in consecutive matches. Moving forward, Dyche may need to focus on building his team’s strategy around maximizing the potential of these key players.
The contrasting performances against Bournemouth and Aston Villa highlight the inconsistency in Everton’s play. While they’re showing signs of improvement in some areas, they’re also facing setbacks that negate their progress. This situation presents a complex challenge for Dyche as he seeks to stabilize the team’s performance and results.