James Tarkowski, a stalwart in Everton’s defense since his free transfer from Burnley in 2022, has been a constant presence in the team’s Premier League lineup. However, his absence from the recent Carabao Cup match against Southampton has raised concerns. The defender has been struggling with a persistent back issue, which dates back to the latter part of the previous season. Despite playing through discomfort towards the end of last season, it appears that this ongoing problem has finally forced him to take a break from competitive action.

Everton manager Sean Dyche remains optimistic about Tarkowski’s availability for the upcoming crucial match against Leicester City on Saturday. This fixture has taken on heightened importance due to Everton’s disappointing start to the season, making Tarkowski’s potential return all the more significant.
The squad’s depth was further tested in the cup tie, with illness sidelining three key players: Vitalii Mykolenko, Dominic Calvert-Lewin, and James Garner. Dyche is hopeful that this trio will recover in time for the Leicester game, which would provide a much-needed boost to the team’s options.

However, the manager’s selection headaches are set to continue, with long-term absentees Seamus Coleman, Nathan Patterson, and Jarrad Branthwaite still unavailable for selection. Their continued absence further emphasizes the importance of having players like Tarkowski fit and ready to play.
The Carabao Cup match itself was a frustrating affair for Everton fans. Despite taking the lead after 20 minutes, the team struggled to maintain their advantage in what was described as a “dire evening of football” at Goodison Park. The inability to find a winning goal in regulation time forced the match into a penalty shootout.
In a cruel twist of fate, it was veteran player Ashley Young whose saved penalty in the sudden-death phase of the shootout sealed Everton’s exit from the League Cup. This outcome was particularly bitter for the Toffees, as it marks another instance of the team being eliminated from this competition via penalties.
The cup exit adds to the mounting pressure on Everton, who are already facing scrutiny due to their poor start in the Premier League. The team’s struggles in both league and cup competitions underscore the importance of the upcoming match against Leicester, where they’ll be hoping for the return of key players like Tarkowski to help turn their fortunes around.
As the team looks to regroup and refocus, the management of player fitness and recovery will be crucial. The potential return of Tarkowski and the illness-stricken trio could provide a much-needed boost, but Dyche will need to carefully balance immediate needs with long-term player health as he seeks to navigate Everton through this challenging period.